| Year | Best Utility | Best Rookie |
| 1991 | Darryl Dempsey Robert Campbell | |
| 1992 | Michael Maher Danny Brennan | |
| 1993 | Shane Jones | |
| 1994 | Dale Walsh | |
| 1995 | Blake Fowler | |
| 1996 | Shannon Johnson | Ryan Fowler |
| 1997 | Jamie Gould | Gavin Butterworth |
| 1998 | Damien Rankine | |
| 1999 | Matthew Purvis Waylon Rankine | |
| 2000 | Richard Fry Jnr | |
| 2001 | Brett Stephens | Adam Rush |
| 2002 | Michael Stavrou | Kyle Fraser |
| 2003 | Damien Rankine | Walter Hemi |
| 2004 | Matthew Purvis | Allan Spence |