| Player | Goals | Year | Round | Opponent |
| Robert Campbell | 14 | 1997 | Rd 5 | Dockers |
| Peter Davies | 12 | 1991 | Rd 2 | Eagles |
| Matthew Hicks | 12 | 1991 | Rd 14 | Elliott |
| Robert Campbell | 12 | 1998 | Rd 7 | Marlinja |
| Adam Pengilly | 11 | 1993 | Rd 14 | Elliott |
| Peter Davies | 10 | 1991 | Rd 3 | Ali Curung |
| John Greenoff | 10 | 1991 | Rd 8 | Ali Curung |
| Gavin Greenoff | 10 | 1992 | Prelim. Final | Ali Curung |
| Shannon Johnson | 10 | 1999 | Rd 7 | Swans |
| Brett Stephens | 10 | 2002 | Rd 7 | Swans |
| Shannon Johnson | 10 | 2003 | Rd 2 | Dockers |